By Adam Pagnucco.

In Part One, I laid out a first cut framework for determining which elementary schools might be targeted for closure.  That framework included projected capacity utilization in the 2032-33 school year, projected capacity utilization in nearby schools and facility condition as measured by MCPS’s facility condition index.  Using these factors, any consultant should be capable of identifying groups of schools that could be candidates for closures and consolidations.  Part Two identified one group in Rockville.  Part Three looked at a group in Chevy Chase and Kensington.  Part Four discussed a group in Germantown.  Now let’s examine a group in Gaithersburg.

Gaithersburg ES, Harriet R. Tubman ES and South Lake ES are clustered around Olde Towne Gaithersburg.  In the 2032-33 school year, projected capacity utilization rates are 58% for Gaithersburg, 71% for Tubman and 75% for South Lake.  Tubman is a new school and South Lake was renovated three years ago.  Both have some of the best facility conditions in MCPS, so they don’t seem like optimal candidates for closure.

That said, this area has capacity utilization issues.  Are redrawn boundaries sufficient to deal with them or would a consultant recommend closing Gaithersburg ES?  Of note is that Gaithersburg ES is projected to have 457 students in 2032-33 while the combined excess capacity of Tubman and South Lake is projected to be 387 students.  Strawberry Knoll ES, which sends its students to the same middle school as Gaithersburg ES, is projected to have an excess capacity of 112 students.

There are two complications here.

First, these three schools do not have the same receiving schools.  While Tubman and Gaithersburg ES are in the same high school cluster (Gaithersburg HS), Tubman sends students to Forest Oak MS and Gaithersburg ES sends students to Gaithersburg MS.  South Lake is in a different high school cluster altogether (Watkins Mills HS).  That would be relevant for any closures and shifts.

Second, South Lake’s service area consists of three detached islands, one of the most bizarre shapes in all of MCPS.  The state requires transportation issues to be considered in any school closure decisions.  MCPS just spent $44 million renovating South Lake, so they would be foolish to close it, but would transportation issues here spawn boundary shifts affecting closure decisions for other schools?

Folks, nothing is simple at MCPS!

Descriptive stats and service area maps for the three schools appear below.

Gaithersburg ES, Gaithersburg

Enrollment, 2032-33: 457

Capacity, 2032-33: 793

Utilization: 2032-33: 58%

Last year renovated/modernized: 1983

Facility Condition Index: 0.518180 (66th of 135 elementary schools)

Gaithersburg’s service area map.

Harriet R. Tubman ES, Gaithersburg

Enrollment, 2032-33: 468

Capacity, 2032-33: 656

Utilization: 2032-33: 71%

Last year renovated/modernized: 2022 (new school)

Facility Condition Index: 0.13118 (3rd of 135 elementary schools)

Harriet Tubman’s service area map.

South Lake ES, Gaithersburg

Enrollment, 2032-33: 583

Capacity, 2032-33: 782

Utilization: 2032-33: 75%

Last year renovated/modernized: 2023

Facility Condition Index: 0.145687 (4th of 135 elementary schools)

South Lake’s service area map.

Next: more Gaithersburg.

Note: As I wrote in Part One, I have zero affiliation with MCPS and no inside knowledge of any plans on closures, consolidations or boundary shifts.  If I were to ask MCPS about their intentions, I am 100 percent sure they would direct me to their public presentation and say, “No decisions have been made at this time.”  My work in no way represents MCPS.