By Adam Pagnucco.
Shortly after County Executive-elect Will Jawando announced his selection of Takoma Park Police Chief Antonio DeVaul as the county’s next chief of police, it began. Emails and texts flew like poison snowballs. Documents circulated. Questions arose, some in public but mostly in private. And now we have the first test of an administration that is not yet even in office. So what will happen?
Will DeVaul be the next police chief?
Let’s start with the issue reported throughout local media: a Park and Planning Commission Office of Internal Audit (OIA) finding of fraud against DeVaul when he was chief of the Park Police. This finding concerned a trip by Park Police employees, including DeVaul, to a 2015 expo in Orlando hosted by police equipment vendor W.W. Grainger, Inc. A complaint alleged that Grainger paid for the trip, which included “free food, alcohol and theme park tickets.”
When DeVaul was asked about this by the auditor, he initially claimed, “he did not think anyone attended.” Further, “he checked his Outlook calendar and stated, ‘It doesn’t look like I was away at conference in February 2015’.” He also stated, “he was sure that the Commission did not do business with the exhibitor.” DeVaul claimed to be having “problems with his email” that limited his ability to check on what happened at the expo.
However, Grainger later confirmed that Park Police employees did attend the event, and when the auditor forwarded the company’s communication to DeVaul, he “stated he now recalls the event.” The company also supplied the auditor a list of nine employees who attended the event, including DeVaul, and stated that “they all selected that Grainger could pay for their registration fee, hotel and air.”
The auditor wrote this conclusion.
*****
Audit Conclusion: Grainger’s payment and the Park Police’s acceptance of conference expenses in 2015 and 2016 is a direct violation of the Commission’s Purchasing Manual (Section 2-550 Kickbacks/Collusion/Bribery) and Commission Practice No.2-24, Ethics, (acceptance of a gift).
Per Commission Practice No. 3-31, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, Fraud is defined as “any act, omission, fraud statement/report or concealment involving the intentional breach of a legal or equitable duty or the violation of federal, state, local laws or M-NCPPC policies which results in damage to the agency in any way …”
The Montgomery County Park Police Department procured $49,283.69 of equipment and supplies from Grainger in FY16.
Based on the above definition of fraud, the OIA reasonably concludes Chief DeVaul’s actions support a conclusion of fraud. Chief DeVaul purposely tried to influence the result of the audit in an attempt to conceal expo attendance and compensation from Grainger. This conclusion is supported by Chief DeVaul’s knowledge of the Commission’s position on the acceptance of travel expense payments from Grainger coupled with his actions and responses to the OIA regarding who attended, reason for attending (active shooting demonstration) and who paid for expo expenses.
In addition, the approval by command staff, and completion of active shooting training, for Grainger, a Commission vendor, meets the definition of abuse, per Commission Practice 3-31. Abuse is defined as “Improper use of or misapplication of actual or apparent M-NCPPC authority, including, without limitation, authority granted or exercised in conjunction with Commission Merit System Rules and Regulations and other official agency policies, Administrative Practices or Procedures.”
*****
DeVaul is pushing back against the finding of the audit. According to the Banner:
DeVaul told The Banner that he did not commit fraud and that he was the target of anonymous retaliatory complaints in 2017 stemming from his support of a lieutenant who brought racial discrimination allegations against two high-ranking white senior officers, one of whom stayed on the job after DeVaul suspended him.
“After I supported the officers, I was subjected to no less than 10 anonymous complaints,” DeVaul said.
Jawando is backing DeVaul and told Fox 5, “I’ve seen subsequent investigations that have cleared him, and we are happy to make those available as long as there’s no legal reason we can’t.”
I asked to see the results of those investigations on Wednesday, and as of this writing, I have not received them.
But let’s address DeVaul’s allegation that he is the target of anonymous complaints. That is undisputedly true. Soon after Jawando announced his selection of DeVaul, I was sent multiple anonymous emails making a huge number of allegations against DeVaul stemming from his tenures at the Park Police and at the Takoma Park Police Department. One of these emails was a 6,181-word epic diatribe with allegations ranging from banal to serious to hilarious. DeVaul has enemies, that’s for sure. I haven’t seen anything like this against an executive nominee other than Charles Bailey, whom County Executive Marc Elrich picked to lead the fire department (and ultimately withdrew). But the allegations against Bailey were less sweeping and an inspector general’s report finally sealed the fate of his nomination.
There is another issue for the council to consider. The internal audit cited by the media is a wide ranging 133-page document that goes far beyond DeVaul. It listed thirteen specific complaints about a host of issues inside the department. The audit investigated nine and substantiated three, including the one above about DeVaul itself.
But what gave rise to all of these complaints in the first place?
Reading through the overflowing amount of material from this document and others, one gets the impression of a department in turmoil, with competing factions targeting each other with complaints and more. It was not a happy place to work. DeVaul was one of many people who were targeted, and aside from the specific finding of fraud, it’s difficult to assign fault exclusively to him or any other individual(s). But top management sets the culture of a workplace, and the Park Police of that era did not have a healthy one. That issue may be even more important than the fraud finding because it raises the question of what kind of county police chief DeVaul might be.
So will Jawando get his way? That depends on these wild cards.
First, five new council members will be joining the eleven member county council. Elrich is one of them, and he considered picking DeVaul as police chief in 2019. What will these new members think?
Second, the county government unions have not yet weighed in, at least not publicly. MCGEO and the police union have frosty relationships with Jawando, and for the police, the identity of the chief is an existential question. Two other unions represent the Park Police and the Takoma Park Police Department. Will they have anything to say?
Third, will any more hard evidence drop? There are TONS of allegations, but ones without corroboration – especially anonymous ones – must be regarded with skepticism. With the audit already out there, what’s next?
Fourth, if DeVaul makes it to a public interview by the council, what will he be asked and how will he respond? He better be ready for anything. One question I have heard many times is whether his service in small police departments is adequate preparation for leading a big department like the county’s. DeVaul’s task will be to convince the council that he is the best possible choice to lead the department in a time of troubles.
Finally, there is the fate of a new administration. Jawando’s pick was greeted with surprise by the president of the police union and the chair of the county’s Advisory Commission on Policing. He faces a tough road with a skeptical and perplexed council that could take its time deciding DeVaul’s fate.
The experience of Jawando’s predecessor is instructive. Elrich’s disastrous pick of Tonya Chapman to be his police chief in 2019 was a turning point for his administration, as the council began to lose confidence in his appointment decision making. That was followed in 2020 by the resignation of Elrich’s top manager after an ethics issue. In retrospect, Elrich never truly recovered from these early problems.
And so Jawando had better hope that he can get the council on board with DeVaul and that DeVaul will go on to become an outstanding chief. If the nomination collapses, Jawando’s future appointments will encounter increasingly aggressive scrutiny by the council and his image inside the police department – already problematic at best – will further decline.
The stakes are high. Will this dice roll pay off? Or will an early snake eyes bite the new county executive?
